What Is Expungement Under Penal Code § 1203.4?
California "expungement" — technically a dismissal under Penal Code § 1203.4 — allows a person who successfully completed probation to ask the court to withdraw their guilty or no-contest plea (or set aside the verdict), enter a plea of not guilty, and dismiss the case. The statute provides that the person is then released from the "penalties and disabilities" of the conviction. To most private employers and background-check companies, the conviction shows as dismissed — not as a standing conviction.
It is the most commonly used record-clearing remedy in California, but it is not the only one — and not always the most powerful. Depending on your goals, a felony reduction, arrest-record sealing, or a legal-invalidity vacatur may accomplish more. That is especially true for non-citizens, for whom a § 1203.4 dismissal provides no immigration benefit at all.
Who Is Eligible for Expungement?
Most people convicted in California state court who were granted probation can qualify. Generally, you must be able to show that:
- The court granted you probation — for a misdemeanor or a felony — and you completed it, or the court terminated it early.
- All court-ordered fines, fees, and restitution have been paid.
- You are not serving a sentence for another offense, are not on probation in another case, and have no pending criminal charges.
- Every condition of probation was satisfied or excused by the court.
Probation violations complicate a petition but do not always bar one. Where someone did not complete probation cleanly, the court may still grant the dismissal in the interests of justice — and a strong showing of rehabilitation becomes the most important part of the filing. Where needed, I can also seek early termination of probation as part of the same effort.
Who Is Not Eligible — and What Are the Limits?
Some convictions fall outside § 1203.4 altogether:
- State prison sentences. If your conviction resulted in a sentence to California state prison (as opposed to county jail under realignment), § 1203.4 dismissal is generally unavailable. The usual path is a Certificate of Rehabilitation and, ultimately, a gubernatorial pardon.
- Certain sex offenses. Section 1203.4(b) excludes specified sex offenses, including convictions under Penal Code §§ 288 and 288.5, among others.
- Federal convictions. A California state court cannot expunge a federal conviction; federal post-conviction record relief is extremely limited and follows different rules.
Even when expungement is available, it has real limits. Read them carefully — the "What Expungement Does Not Do" section below explains them, because relying on a dismissal for something it cannot do is a common, costly mistake.
The Expungement Process, Step by Step
- Get your record. We start with your California Department of Justice criminal history (your "RAP sheet," obtained by Live Scan) and the court files, to identify every case, its disposition, and anything still owed.
- Eligibility review. I check each conviction against the § 1203.4 requirements and flag problems — probation violations, unpaid restitution, cases in other counties — before the court does.
- Prepare and file the petition. The petition (form CR-180) is filed in the court where the conviction occurred, with a supporting declaration where the case calls for one.
- Serve the prosecutor. The prosecution receives the petition and an opportunity to object — most routine petitions are unopposed.
- Decision or hearing. Many petitions are granted on the papers. If the court sets a hearing, I appear and argue why dismissal serves the interests of justice; in most cases your presence is not required.
- Order and record update. The signed order (CR-181) goes to the Department of Justice, which updates your state record to reflect the dismissal.
Total timing is typically a few months from start to finish, but it varies considerably by county, the age of the case, and court backlog. Older cases with archived files often take longer.
What Expungement Does
- Employment. After a dismissal, you may honestly answer "no" to most private-employer questions asking whether you have been convicted. Labor Code § 432.7 also bars private employers from asking about, or using, dismissed convictions in hiring decisions.
- Background checks. Most commercial background checks stop reporting the conviction; the case typically appears as dismissed rather than as a conviction.
- Licensing, housing, and education. A dismissal improves outcomes with professional licensing boards, rental applications, and admissions — many boards and landlords treat a dismissed case very differently from an open conviction.
- An official record of rehabilitation. The court's order is a formal acknowledgment that you completed your sentence and earned the fresh start.
What Expungement Does Not Do
A § 1203.4 dismissal is valuable, but it is not an erasure. Understanding its limits matters as much as understanding its benefits:
- It does not erase the record. The case still exists. Courts, law enforcement, and government agencies can still see it; it shows as dismissed rather than disappearing.
- It still counts as a prior. A dismissed conviction can still be used to enhance future charges or sentences, and in several other legal settings.
- It does not restore firearm rights. A § 1203.4 dismissal does not restore gun rights. That requires a § 17(b) reduction (for wobbler offenses) or a gubernatorial pardon.
- It does not help with immigration. Under federal immigration law, a conviction dismissed under § 1203.4 is still a "conviction" — the dismissal does not change deportability or any other immigration consequence. But a vacatur based on the legal invalidity of the plea — under Penal Code § 1473.7 — can. See the next section.
- Disclosure is still required in some settings. You must disclose the conviction when running for public office, applying for state or local licensing, and in certain public contracting (§ 1203.4(a)(1)). Government Live Scan checks will also show the case as dismissed.
Vacating Convictions That Harm Your Immigration Status
For non-citizens, a § 1203.4 dismissal changes nothing: immigration law disregards it because it is rehabilitative. But California has built remedies aimed at a different problem — convictions obtained when the person was never properly advised that the plea would make them deportable. These remedies attack the legal validity of the plea itself, and that distinction is exactly what immigration law honors.
Penal Code § 1473.7 — The Main Vehicle
Section 1473.7 allows a person who is no longer in criminal custody — including people who completed their sentence years ago, and even people who have already been deported — to move to vacate a conviction when the plea was legally invalid due to prejudicial error that damaged their ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the plea's adverse immigration consequences. It covers both defense counsel's failure (under Padilla v. Kentucky) and the court's failure to advise. Key points:
- No finding of ineffective assistance of counsel is required — the focus is the prejudicial error itself.
- The movant may appear through counsel — critical for clients who are outside the United States.
- The burden is a preponderance of the evidence, and if the motion is granted, the plea is withdrawn.
Penal Code § 1016.5 Motion
The older remedy: where the court failed to give the required statutory immigration advisement before the plea (warning that a plea "may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion, and denial of naturalization"), § 1016.5 permits a motion to vacate. The defendant must show they were not advised, that they would not have pleaded guilty had they been, and must act with reasonable diligence (Zamudio). Today § 1473.7 is usually the broader and better vehicle — but § 1016.5 still matters in older cases.
Habeas Corpus and Padilla Claims (PC § 1473)
For those still in custody — including on probation or supervised release — habeas corpus remains available for Padilla ineffective-assistance claims: where counsel misadvised, or failed to advise, a non-citizen client of the deportation consequences.
Penal Code § 18.5 Sentence Reduction
A 365-day misdemeanor sentence can be reduced retroactively to 364 days under § 18.5. That one-day difference is designed to keep people below the one-year thresholds that trigger certain federal immigration consequences — including some aggravated-felony classifications. It is a narrow tool, but sometimes a decisive one.
Penal Code § 236.14 — Human-Trafficking Victims
Victims of human trafficking may petition to vacate convictions (and seal arrests) that were the direct result of having been trafficked. This vacatur rests on the conviction never having been just — not on rehabilitation.
Why This Works for Immigration — and Expungement Does Not
Federal immigration law, under the Matter of Thomas line of cases, disregards vacaturs granted for rehabilitative, equitable, or immigration-avoidance reasons — but honors vacaturs based on a procedural or substantive legal defect in the underlying plea. Section 1473.7 is drafted to rest on legal invalidity, which is precisely what immigration courts require. Choosing the right vehicle is not a technicality; it is the whole case.
A Strategic Caution
A granted motion reopens the criminal case, and the prosecution may reinstate the original charges. Filing a § 1473.7 motion without a plan for the reopened case — a negotiated immigration-safe disposition, or a defense ready to go — can leave a client worse off than before. These filings require careful advice first.
Why Choose Me for Your Record-Clearing Case
Post-conviction work rewards lawyers who understand the whole picture — sentencing, criminal law, and immigration — because the "right" remedy depends entirely on what you need the clearing to accomplish.
If a past conviction is holding back your job, housing, license, or immigration status, contact me for a free, confidential consultation.
Expungement Frequently Asked Questions
How long does expungement take?
Typically a few months from filing to a signed order, depending on the county, the age of the case, and court backlog. Cases requiring a hearing or archived old files can take longer.
Will it show on a background check?
Most commercial background checks will stop reporting it as a conviction; the case shows as dismissed. Government Live Scan checks — for licensing and public employment — will still show the case marked dismissed
Can a DUI be expunged?
Yes. DUI convictions under Vehicle Code § 23152 are eligible under § 1203.4 once probation is complete and everything is paid. The dismissal does not remove the DUI from your DMV driving record, where it remains for 10 years.
Can I expunge a felony?
Often, yes — if you were granted probation and completed it, including county-jail felony sentences under realignment. If you served state prison time, § 1203.4 is unavailable and the path is a Certificate of Rehabilitation and pardon. A § 17(b) reduction can be paired for wobbler offenses.
Do I have to appear in court?
Usually not. Your attorney can file the petition and appear at any hearing for you; many petitions are granted on the papers alone. Clients who are outside California — or outside the country — routinely complete the process without traveling.
Will expungement help my immigration case?
No. Federal immigration law treats a § 1203.4 dismissal as if the conviction still exists. Non-citizens should get immigration advice before filing anything — and should ask instead about § 1473.7 vacatur, which is designed for legally invalid pleas and can be recognized by the immigration courts.
I was never told my plea could get me deported — can anything be done?
Possibly, yes. Penal Code § 1473.7 exists for exactly this: it allows a conviction to be vacated when prejudicial error — by counsel or by the court — undermined your ability to understand and accept the plea's immigration consequences. The older § 1016.5 motion covers cases where the court omitted the required statutory advisement. Reviewing the plea transcript is the first step.
I already got deported — can I still challenge my conviction?
Yes. Section 1473.7 is available to people no longer in criminal custody, including those already removed from the United States, and you may appear through your attorney without returning. Bad immigration advice years ago is not a closed door.